WSO2 is now Choreo LabsLearn more

Trusted AI Governance
Build

Create agents and AI apps with the tools and languages your teams already use.

Connect

Link agents securely to your APIs, data, models and business systems.

Run

Deploy, observe and operate agents and AI apps reliably at any scale.

Govern

Control identity, access, cost and policy for every agent in production.

Agent Management

Developer Platform

  • API Management Cloud

    Design, secure and publish APIs with governance and analytics built in.

    Sign Up Now
  • Integration Cloud

    Connect apps, data and AI agents with low-code and pro-code integration.

    Sign Up Now
  • Identity & Access Management Cloud

    Secure sign-in and access for customers, partners, workforce and agents.

    Sign Up Now
  • Agent Management Cloud

    Build, run and govern AI agents with full visibility and control.

    Sign Up Now
  • Developer Platform Cloud

    Ship cloud-native apps faster on an internal developer platform.

    Sign Up Now

Self-Hosted

Full control over your stack. Deploy directly to your own servers, bare metal, cloud, or Kubernetes environment. Your data never leaves your perimeter.

Product Downloads
Choreo Labs
AI Governance
Platform
Solutions
Resources
Blog

Bus architecture to handle inbound and outbound calls with BPEL

Business processes play a major role in complex, long-running business processes in the modern enterprise. Such business processes might automate such business tasks as ordering and billing, customer or employee account provisioning, financial recordkeeping, auditing, and archiving, supply chain management, and many more.

Within SOA-based solutions a common technology for describing and executing business processes is BPEL (Business Process Execution Language). In an SOA environment, a business interaction with a user or a system results in a call to a Web service representing the business process. Such services may be implemented conveniently using BPEL deployed inside a BPEL engine such as the WSO2 Business Process Server (BPS.)

Since the BPEL engine exposes the process as a service, consumers can invoke the business process using the service interface and whichever of the bindings is most convenient. However, this integration pattern creates a point-to-point connection between the business process and the consumer - something that over time can result in “SOA spaghetti” and make management and evolution of the SOA platform difficult.

The pattern proposed here as a solution avoids this point-to-point connection by introducing a mediation layer using a bus architecture. An Enterprise Service Bus (ESB) presents a face to the consumers, takes the requests to execute the business processes and routes them to the business process services exposed by the BPEL engine. Changes to the system (either the consumers or the BPEL services) can be managed largely within the bus, simplifying versioning, new or alternate protocol deployment, monitoring, security configurations, logging and auditing, migration or scaling of services, etc. The result is more flexibility, greater robustness, and greater insight and manageability of the SOA.

Invoking external services becomes an essential part of BPEL logic. As a result, BPEL engines such as the WSO2 BPS need to connect to various other service endpoints within the service platform.

Commonly, BPEL activities are wired to service endpoints using direct partner links and service endpoint URLs. As a result, point-to-point integration is created between the business process layer and back-end services. These tightly-coupled P2P connections lead to complexity and limit system changes and enhancements, just the problem we were avoiding by fronting the BPEL service with an ESB!

To address this lack of loose coupling for our WSO2 BPS users, we’ve often used a pattern derived from the bus architecture. In a nutshell, this pattern introduces another (conceptually at least) instance of the WSO2 Enterprise Service Bus to mediate between the business processes and the back-end services.

Such a layered architecture looks like this:

Each BPS call that goes to the services layer, does so through the ESB. The ESB invokes the actual services, allowing it to manage all the endpoints and ensures traffic participates in the benefits of routing through the ESB. The diagram above shows two ESB layers. But, in a physical deployment, in most cases, it is deployed as a single ESB instance. Converting the above architecture to a bus architecture helps understand it better. Therefore, lets look at the same thing in a bus architecture.

The above diagram shows that all the upstream consumer channels, business process server (BPEL engine) and the services connect to the same ESB. The ESB wires each component.
This pattern provides a flexible and clean architecture to integrate consumer channels, business processes and backend services.

There are however a few drawbacks to this pattern which need to be balanced with the advantages discussed above. First, this will add a new component to the deployment architecture (the ESB) to be managed in the production environments. Second, two additional layers adding to the communication flows by introducing the ESB may add some latency (typically minimal) to a process invocation. Consider the consequences of these drawbacks when designing your architecture around this pattern.

Asanka Abeysinghe, Director of Solutions Architecture
Asanka’s blog: https://asanka.abeysinghe.org/